- 11-29-2012, 11:00 AM #1
One of the threads about Xbox music not syncing properly prompted me to download the Zune software and see if I could re-create the issues people were having. I never owned a Zune, and WP8 has been my first Windows "mobile" experience since I sold my VX6900 (a Verizon-branded HTC Touch) and moved to the iPhone. The Zune software is amazing, though... it's *really* good. Since I installed it I keep playing around with it and trying to figure out why MS dropped it. After a couple of days of contemplation, I think I've figured it out:
The iPod was wildly successful. Hugely. When you say "the iPhone doubles as an iPod" or "the iPhone has a built-in iPod" that means something because of the iPod's success. The Zune - on the other hand - was a commercial flop. The only MS flops bigger than the Zune were Bob and the Kins, heh. Saying "Windows Phone 8 has Zune built-in" would probably garner grimaces (at worst) or blank stares (at best) in reply from all but the most diehard MS/Zune fans. Xbox, however... that's wildly successful as well. Hugely. How many Xbox consoles were sold on black Friday? Some ungodly amount? Anyway, "Xbox" has TONS more recognition and positive vibes than does Zune; saying "Windows Phone 8 has Xbox music built-in" is much better.
So yeah, now I get why MS dropped Zune for Xbox Music. I can't imagine that MS is going to sully the Xbox brand with poor performance on WP8 devices. I have faith that they'll fix all the issues that are being encountered.
Anyway, just some thoughts I've had recently, thought I'd share 'em. :)
- 11-29-2012, 11:25 AM #4
The problem is not that they dropped the name 'Zune'.. Nobody cares about that. The problem is they took a program that was awesome and instead of keeping some of the key insides, they started over on Windows 8. Yes, the market share for Zune and Windows Phone 7 was not huge, but it is still was millions of users. All these users were using Zune to sync their devices..
For years Microsoft has had Zune pass, not called XBox Music pass or whatever.... It's been on Xbox now for a little while as well. People like me have downloaded tons and tons of subscription music to play on our Zunes, or Windows Phones or just on our Windows machines. I have a Zune plugged into my Ford Sync that I use all the time. If you have a Zune for as long as I have you're a true fanboy. :)
With Windows Phone 8 there is no way to get any of that locally stored subscription music onto my phone. No way at all. If I want it, I have to download them one at a time on my phone.. How lame is that? That sync tool is truly terrible. Is it the end of the world? Obviously not. The people I do really feel sorry for are the ones who actually have purchsed Videos from XBox Live that are unable to actually view them on their phones. Three screens and the cloud? False. :)
It's all a perfect example of Microsoft silos and I'm so glad Sinofsky got shown the door. Those big wigs that don't work with other divisions need to go.
- 11-29-2012, 11:42 AM #7
I know it hurts, but they are trying to phase out your way of syncing. For a person just now being introduced to mobile music, Xbox Music makes a lot of sense. They will not even bother with the USB cable or the terrible WP sync software. They will just wait until their library populates on their phone and then they will stream their music. If they listen to a song often enough, they will hold down on that song to select "download." That's it. They will never even contemplate tethering their phone to a PC.
- 11-29-2012, 12:03 PM #9
- 11-29-2012, 12:11 PM #10
With that said, try to picture the local sync software as a benefit, not a necessity.
- 11-29-2012, 12:15 PM #11
I've been a Zune owner since day 1. Got a 30, 80,120, and a 64HD. I'm a big music fan. I like to buy music. So storing it locally is the only way for me. Having my Lumia 900 sync for me the way my Zunes do is great.
I won't upgrade to the new phones until this is ironed out.
- 11-29-2012, 12:25 PM #12
I have had Zunes too. I still have a Zune HD, which is a very good music player. I like the Zune software. I felt a little anxiety when I plugged my Lumia 920 into my computer and the Zune software didn't recognize. I tried the new sync software and was shocked by how bare-bones it is. I can't even drag and drop an individual song onto my phone?
Then I realized how I'm supposed to use my phone in the age of the cloud. People don't buy albums anymore. We just hear a song we like, use bing to recognize it, and download it directly to our library. We use SmartDJ to hear new music, hear a song we like, and download it directly to our library. Soon, we will tell a friend about a cool new song and use NFC to share it. MS is expecting people like you and me to adapt.
That being said, I am disappointed with the SmartDJ feature. I don't want to start with just a song or just an artist. I want to create a playlist and create a SmartDJ from that. I want SmartDJ to be more diverse. I like the Pandora or Slacker way of creating stations. I want to be able to use sliders to tell Xbox Music how much of my local music to play, how much to stream, how much new music to mix in, etc.
- 11-29-2012, 12:27 PM #13
The point is, you can do everything you need to from the phone. You don't need a computer for anything.
- 11-29-2012, 12:32 PM #14
- 11-29-2012, 12:37 PM #15
2.) I'm a little confused as to what functionality you expect from Smart DJ that Pandora has. Doesn't Pandora create stations based on what you type in? Artist, song, etc.?
- 11-29-2012, 12:51 PM #16
11-29-2012, 12:51 PM #17
- 183 Posts
Master List Of Issues With XBox Music On WP8 - Microsoft Community
The Zune software synced music, videos, pictures, podcasts, etc. It did a fine job of doing that with my WP7 devices. Now they got rid of that, and created these stupid connector apps that are still in beta that crash all the time. There's Windows Media Player, and regular file transferring. What MS did was kill off a great syncing app that did a great job of doing everything and then replaced it with multiple apps that don't do everything, and of top of that, do what they do very poorly. It's more than just music. Read through the threads.
Personally speaking for myself. I don't give a flying !@#$ about XBox Music, Pandora, Spotify, or streaming music. I don't listen to music that way. I have my own library of music I listen to. If I like something I'll buy it and download it. And I expect to put it on all my devices with very little to no effort. I don't want it eating up my data plan through streaming. When I want to listen to a certain song or album, I don't want to run a situation in where I have a crappy connection or I can't download it locally because I'm on a plane or whatever. It's pretty simple really. They should have just kept the software, renamed it to whatever they wanted, updated the logos, and added support for WP8 devices. WP7 never had issues like the ones described and it certainly did not completely screw up the metadata on my music library. Wrong album art, wrong artist names, wrong song titles, wrong track orders, etc, etc, etc. The Zune software never did any of that.
11-29-2012, 12:53 PM #18
- 4 Posts
I just got my Lumia 920 in the mail (after having a Samsung focus for 2 years). I'm confused at how I"m supposed to get my Xbox subscription music on my phone.
Is the only way to download it wirelessly? I ask because on my Samsung Focus it seemed that if I downloaded music over the air it would download a (noticeably) low quality version. Is that different in wp8?
- 11-29-2012, 01:00 PM #19
As for liking and disliking songs, have you taken any notice to the "heart" icon above the repeat and shuffle icons? It has 3 settings: a full heart, empty heart, and broken heart. I'm guessing that these might mean: like, mutual, dislike. I know nothing about it and I'm curious myself. It would make sense to me that they influence Smart DJ.
11-29-2012, 01:11 PM #20
- 1,262 Posts
Though WP8 is going in this direction, you still have the option to not use the cloud. There are a few steps you will need to take in advance to keep you from having a mess on your hands.
First, turn off Xbox Music cloud collection on the phone. There is also a setting on the Xbox Music app for Win 8 PC that you will need to turn off. I'm not at a Win 8 PC atm and cannot remember the setting. Actually, I think there are two settings that need to be turned off on the PC side.
Since WP8 now shows up as a mass storage device you have more options to sync the device than previously. I have used Media Monkey in the past and its a great program. Its not free though. I know this is incomplete but so is this whole topic.
- 11-29-2012, 01:26 PM #21
I use the heart icon just in case it does something. It used to be handy in that if you disliked a song, it would "unsync" that song the next time you connected your phone to your computer. I wonder if it has some equivalent function now. As far as it improving SmartDJ results, I haven't noticed a difference, but I admit I don't use SmartDJ very much. I'm curious if people have noticed improved SmartDJ results after using the heart icon over a period of time.
I still would like more customizable SmartDJ stations. On Slacker, I have a work channel, a heavy music channel, and a channel for my girlfriend. Each is seeded with many bands that define the station, each is very different from the others, and each gets better and better the more I listen and rate songs. Slacker also allows me to customize what gets played on a channel. SmartDJ is like Pandora or Slacker for beginners.
11-29-2012, 01:28 PM #22
- 66 Posts
First, streaming is not always possible (it's not always good - often long pauses between tracks, etc). Unlimited data is certainly not the norm and what about periods of limited/zero reception or expensive data roaming? In short, people need to be able to manage the music on their phone quickly and easily. Drag and drop doesn't really cut it IMO, so you either use the awful sync app (and even then, selecting music is a pain) or you download directly to the phone (where you have to select each track from a long list of songs sorted only in alpha order). Why not just sync/download whole playlists of songs?
Second, virtually all my listening is done on a WP8 phone... and yet nothing I do on the phone seems to sync to the cloud or my other devices - it doesn't seem to note the songs I stream to or download to or delete from my phone, nor do the heart/full heart/broken heart ratings sync. Managing playlists on the phone is impossible too.
It all adds up to an unreasonably difficult and disappointing experience. It should just work, but it doesn't. I will not be renewing my Xbox Music sub, put it that way. I am left praying Spotify bothers to make an app for WP8!
- 11-29-2012, 04:38 PM #24
11-29-2012, 08:07 PM #25
- 42 Posts
I agree with every single thing you've written. This music system they've gone and created is just plain bad. Way to go MS... you took something that was elegant, simple and flexible and made it like getting a colonoscopy performed by a jackhammer dipped in lemon juice and salt.
- By jake69 in forum ZuneReplies: 6Last Post: 12-17-2012, 03:24 PM
- By Laura Knotek in forum The "Off Topic" LoungeReplies: 22Last Post: 11-20-2012, 10:58 AM
- By anodynamic in forum ZuneReplies: 0Last Post: 08-31-2012, 12:33 PM
- By iop777 in forum ZuneReplies: 3Last Post: 08-30-2012, 11:31 AM
- By Winterfang in forum Windows Phone 7Replies: 0Last Post: 06-20-2012, 07:23 PM