- 11-05-2012, 01:47 PM #1
I generally detest the look of glossy finish, but I've been giving it some thought and I noticed my 900's matte finish seemed to make it easy for it to slip out of my hand before I put the rubber bumper case on it.
Now I'm close to buying a new Lumia 920. I would normally just go for the matte since I don't like glossy as much, but I remembered that my 900 was pretty slippery and the 920 is going to be even bigger and harder to grip, so I got to thinking.... maybe the glossy surface will be a bit "tackier" so it will stick in your hand better.
Can anyone confirm this?
If so, I'll probably go with glossy white. I just can't see myself putting a case on a phone that is already a bit bigger and heavier than I'd like it to be. :dry
Option #2 of course would be to just go with an 820... but I'm not ready to give in just yet.
- 11-05-2012, 01:54 PM #3
Not sure cos of it being a demo unit with gazillion fingerprints and other smudge, but the glossy one was more grippy. Theres not much friction on the matte one, but the glossy is quite rubber-like in the grip feeling.
Oh, you already put it in better words in your OP: IMO the glossy one was indeed much "tackier" and sticked to the hand much more than the matte black.
I like the feel of the matte much much better, but I have hard time settling for a black phone.. so boring while the red looks simply amazing, but it feels nowhere near as nice and premium in my hands.
To elaborate, I got to hold both phones (or more so both finishes) in my hands at the same time, so this isn't theorycrafting on previous models or pictures.
Last edited by Coreldan; 11-05-2012 at 02:02 PM.
11-05-2012, 01:55 PM #4
- 3,970 Posts
I'm not sure there's that much of a difference. Neither is really slippery.
What I believe makes phones easy to drop ends up being the shape. If the shape of the phone tends to make you only hold it on the edges, then you're more likely to drop it. Fewer and smaller contact points with your hands.
If the phone ends up resting on your palm, then you're less likely to drop it. Bigger contact points.
- 11-05-2012, 02:00 PM #5
- 11-05-2012, 02:04 PM #9
I think it all depends on the material the device is made from and the form factor. I've played with the S3, and it was impossible for me to hold due to the thinness, light weight and slippery finish.
- 11-05-2012, 02:08 PM #10
The S3 is impossible to hold (as well as impossible to keep running). This is true. But it has a "coated" finish -- almost lacquer. I'd imagine the gloss on the Nokia is similar to the 900 in white, which is far less slippery.
- 11-05-2012, 02:51 PM #12
I'm thinking glossy is going to actually be easier to grip with a little humdity, which is always present in your hand, especially here in Florida.
I'd prefer matte generally, but seeing as how my 900 has a cracked screen now from being dropped one too many times, and the 920 is even bigger which could very well potentially make it harder to grasp, I'm thinking glossy. At least white won't show the little scratches and swirl marks quite so much.
- 11-05-2012, 03:02 PM #14
I had a white 900 for a few months, and I've had a black 900 since launch day. The glossy was more tacky, as has been said. Also, I'd have to disagree about the glossy showing more fingerprints. It might get more fingerprints, but they aren't that easy to see. The matte black shows more grease and wear. Also, my black 900 has spots on the edges that have been worn smooth. Don't get me wrong, it's still beautiful. If I take a damp washcloth to it, after it's dry it looks almost perfect.
11-05-2012, 03:03 PM #15
- 186 Posts
I own a glossy white 900 for 2 months now. Previously I owned a Trophy. The amazing thing is that I have not dropped my 900 till now compared to my 1st 2 months with my Trophy when I recalled dropping it a few times. Despite the gloss & smoothness, I find the grip on the 900 is much more sturdier & firmer compared to the Trophy. Take for example the few times I tried fishing out my 900 from my trouser's pocket using just 2 fingers + a thumb as I got trouble putting my whole hand into my pocket. At the moment when the 900 was out of my pocket, I was afraid it would juz slip out of my hand & crash on the floor but to my surprise, it juz hang on like glue to my fingers & thumb. There must be some secret ingredient that Nokia added to the glossy material :D
So that's my take on your query, hope its helpful & informational.
- 11-05-2012, 08:24 PM #19
I experienced the same thing with the original galaxy note. My wife had a black one with a matte back and I had a white one with the glossy back. The glossy stuck in my hand alot better.. the matte back was very slippery for me.
Using a black lumia 900 I felt the same way.. it was very slick for me. Part of it was the shape I'm sure but the matte finish made it slippery for me. I'll be getting the glossy red 920. Maybe it has something to do with how oily/dry your skin is..
- 11-05-2012, 09:19 PM #21
The glossy I'm sure would be even easier to wipe clean though.
- 11-06-2012, 02:39 AM #23