- 06-28-2013, 02:46 PM #1
It's pretty sad really. my iPad 1 kicks my surfaces *** when it comes to taking handwritten notes
noteshelf / penultimate on IOS - take your pick .. there is nothing out there that even comes close to a good simple handwritten note taking application.
OneNote is too complex and does not have any palm/wrist protection - noteAnywhere is far to kludgy and the palm protection implementation is not really that good (it does not automatically move down the page as you write)
come one -- is anyone out there making a decent note taking app!! I'd pay money for one, as it stands I am still using my iPad1 because of this and I tend to leave the surface at home gathering dust
- 06-28-2013, 03:00 PM #3
- 06-28-2013, 04:03 PM #5
yeah - but the ipad doesn't have hardware palm rejection either - but IOS seems to handle it just great in software - penultimate / noteshelf.
is the surface RT really not as good as a first gen iPad for using a stylus to take handwritten notes? that just seems really bad
- 06-28-2013, 04:24 PM #7
I am pretty much at that conclusion as well. So sad really.
For what I use a tablet for (handwritten notes/reading ebooks) the Surface just doesn't do it for me. How it's not able to handle these two simple tasks is quite amazing
Oh well, guess my next tablet will be an iPad then, sticking to Noteshelf / iBooks - frankly, these two apps - i've not found *anything* close to these on the microsoft platform - that and lack of cisco VPN API's, kinda kills the surface for me
sorry this turned in a 'slam the surface' post - but I am so disheartened that a tablet I bought 4 years ago turns out to be actually more useful to me than the one I just got.
- 06-28-2013, 05:00 PM #8
This was my decided factor in getting the Surface Pro instead of the Surface RT. Easily Onenote is my most used app, I love how it shows my handwriting on my windows phone in the same OneNote file synced to SkyDrive. I also like how it translates my handwriting into text if I email my note. The Surface Pro is a great buy for this reason alone. I hope they out the pen technology into the next Surface Rt.
- 06-28-2013, 05:09 PM #9
Looks like it's a next Gen ipad with IOS7 for me. The only reason I am not getting one today is that we're pretty close to an ipad5 launch.
Shame really, as I am using windows 8.1 desktop and Lumia phones.
- 06-28-2013, 06:27 PM #10
There is no advantage I can see to Windows RT, but the Surface RT and iPad are not the only tablets less than $1k. Get a Windows 8 tablet with an Atom processor, way more capability than an iPad with similar battery life. If you want one now get an Atom tablet, if you can wait get a Haswell tablet. No need for an iPad with a 10 year old OS.
- 06-28-2013, 07:14 PM #11
Just because the Surface RT doesn't take handwriting notes well doesn't mean it's pointless. Few people use a stylus anymore. My RT has effectively replaced my laptop. No iPad can do that. And it does it at half the cost and with twice the battery life as the Pro. Obviously you did little to no research before you bought it. No tablet is everything to everybody.
- 06-29-2013, 01:46 AM #12
I also bought my Surface Pro because I wanted it to replace my 15 inch laptop which it does, so with this it is worth the $1400 I paid for it (including Tax, and the warranty bundle.)
Here is a tablet that you might want to consider.
it has Windows 8 Pro on it, and in the Pic is a pen, double check the specs to see if it meets your needs.
- 06-29-2013, 10:28 AM #14
They are totally different devices though. The Surface Pro has a core i5 processor, because of this it has the battery life comparable to a laptop. The Thinkpad Tablet 2 has a low-power Atom processor and has battery life of a tablet. The Surface Pro is a true laptop replacement, the Thinkpad Tablet 2 is a second device like the Surface RT. It really doesn't make sense to compare the THinkpad Tablet 2 to the Surface Pro, they are completely different devices aimed at different things. The Thinkpad sacrifices performance for being fanless and able to last all weekend on a single charge.
- 06-30-2013, 11:12 AM #15
Everything you're saying is totally possible using OneNote and has been for months.
My handwriting is godawful but you get the picture. I used a $5 capacitive stylus that I got for my HP touchpad.
Also, Surface RT has handwriting recognition and it works fantastic, that is NOT a surface pro feature.
Some days I feel as though people that are comparing the RT to an iPad and choosing the iPad are actually using a different, ****tier RT that Microsoft sent to a select group of people. :-\
06-30-2013, 11:40 AM #16
- 760 Posts
The Surface Pros benefit is that it has Wacom technology in the screen so it is pressure sensitive. Meaning if you press harder, there is a thicker line. This is great for artists, graphic designers, etc using full blown Photoshop, but not really necessary for taking notes.
06-30-2013, 11:48 AM #17
- 760 Posts
See what I did there? You may have different priorities that make the iPad better for you. To me and many others, the iPad is a worthless paperweight compared to the Surface RT.
I think you need to research before you make a purchase a little better and also look at other Windows tablet options.
I've used note taking on both iPad and Surface RT, I don't think either one has that much an advantage over the other. And OneNote is a great app, far more powerful than just a "digital sheet of paper."
- 07-01-2013, 01:03 PM #18
Well, I don't really mind about the single tasking of the iPad. It seems, for what I need a tablet for, it fits my needs much better than the surface - i guess it's just my style of working.
People say that you cant compare the surface, and it's much better than the ipad, and yet the ipad appears to work much better with the same capacitive pen than the surface, I get much more fluid writing on it, (see an example pulled from the web below) so I think there is something in the technology/software used with the surface RT that just does not lend itself to using a capacitive pen.
The other deal-breaker for me with the surface/RT is lack of cisco VPN support. No doubt this would not be an issue for the ATOM tablets.
Speaking of Atom - does it seem that more and more manufacturers are going the atom route than the arm one for tablets? Is there a long term future for RT/ARM?
Update - I just tried OneNote again on the surface/RT and it's terrible for handwriting - the *only* thing that can be touching the screen at the time of writing is the tip of the pen - if you have your palm on the screen it wont write where you use the pen until you lift off your palm, otherwise it seems to only accept input where your palm is - you would have at least thought it would also let you ink where the pen is and also 'smudge' where your palm is, but it doesn't - it's almost like it only has 'single point of input in the application.
Last edited by loribinca; 07-01-2013 at 02:15 PM.
- 07-01-2013, 03:03 PM #19
The Surface RT IS BETTER than the iPad FOR MY NEEDS. And that's the case for most people here in the SURFACE FOR WINDOWS RT forum, most of whom probably did some research before purchasing. That doesn't mean it's better for everybody.
Evidently the Microsoft Store does not meet your needs. As I said before, no tablet is everything to everybody. If the iPad best meets YOUR needs, why buy the Surface and then spend time here complaining about things it never claimed to do? I don't get that mentality. It's not like Microsoft's limited selection of apps is a big secret, it's mentioned in every review I've ever read.
07-01-2013, 03:11 PM #20
- 2,247 Posts
For the love of god, just type.Try out my first Windows 8 app, ModernCalc! It's free and I would love to hear your feedback!
Phones: Nokia Lumia 928, HTC Windows Phone 8x, HTC Trophy
PMP: Zune HD 32, Zune 80, Zune 4, Zune 30, Ipod Nano 2nd gen (x4), Ipod touch 16gb 2nd gen
Tablet: Surface for Windows RT
- 07-01-2013, 03:29 PM #21
- 07-01-2013, 04:09 PM #22
- 07-02-2013, 07:30 PM #24
I tried that -- actually bought the app - I had traded emails with the developer as well early on because it was initially not ported to ARM - and to be honest it was the best one I found, the palm block is still a bit kludgy for my liking as you need to move it yourself manually as you move down the page (at least that's how I remembered it working)
It would be great if it automatically moved as you filled the area above it with text - that's how noteshelf works, and works well.
I've been trying to google the specs/resolution of the digitizer on the surface, but I cant find it. but it sure seems to me that it's not as good as the ipad when it comes to pen input. I think it was designed more for 'touch' than handwritten/pen input, is my theory - maybe there is a subtle difference in the technology used.
I am sure if i put screenshots side-by-side using the same pen, to write the same sentence the ipad will look a lot smoother - and this is a gen1 ipad (non-retina) - actually I already tried this, so I know it's the case, which leads me to believe there is something more going on than a lack of note-taking software
I'm still not sure which research i would have needed to have read (from comments above) that would have told me the surface was so weak at taking handwritten notes
oh well.. thanks for peoples feedback on the thread.
07-03-2013, 12:50 AM #25
- 373 Posts
Without a doubt the digitizer on the RT is designed for 10 point touch, not inking.
I have the RT and an HP Elitebook Revolve 810 (with a pen digitizer) and the HP is quite good at taking ink notes (with the pen) while the RT isn't very good at all, even using the same app.
Note Anytime did the best at software smoothing the RT ink, but it's still not great, and doesn't do what the iPad does ink wise.
I'd have to agree that if your goal is inking, the RT isn't the device for you. I stick with keyboard entry on the RT. I've done a bit of light pen notetaking on the HP, but even there I just type so much faster that I just don't do it much at all.
- By DavidVivancos in forum Windows Phone AppsReplies: 19Last Post: 10-29-2013, 03:01 PM
- By jpayne80 in forum Windows Phone 8Replies: 52Last Post: 07-11-2013, 11:16 AM
- By akhil14 in forum Nokia Lumia 720Replies: 2Last Post: 07-06-2013, 02:27 AM
- By crash1989 in forum Windows Phone AppsReplies: 4Last Post: 07-06-2013, 02:15 AM
- By suresh geens in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 1Last Post: 07-05-2013, 11:39 AM